THE LAST PLACE

Tania had always been at the top of her class, even after shifting from a neutral system of grades to an aggressive one of ranks. In the new arena, a few girls jousted bitterly every year for the pinnacle with ill-concealed ferocity that crackled with venom and was spat out sporadically in dour confrontation. This year, Tania had set a taut mouth to the task, juggling with both inspired and slog work. Despite a slightly distressed demeanour after the math test, she looked smug enough for the top spot. That evening, when I heard a hail of footsteps in the hallway, and in a swirl of pigtails, she was lodged breathless in my arms, I knew she had beaten her rivals.

Tania had always been at the top of her class, even after shifting from a neutral system of grades to an aggressive one of ranks. In the new arena, a few girls jousted bitterly every year for the pinnacle with ill-concealed ferocity that crackled with venom and was spat out sporadically in dour confrontation. This year, Tania had set a taut mouth to the task, juggling with both inspired and slog work.

Probably by the slenderest of margins, which makes triumph all the sweeter. A buff report card had now been thrust under my nose. Chubby fingers jabbed viciously at the scores as she recounted her conquest. Her gestures were uncomfortably reminiscent of those one sees on television, when frenzied contestants shake fists and glower whenever they score points in the sporting arena. Seeing Tania’s fulsome, almost vicious, delight in vanquishing her rivals, I could dimly comprehend what blazing motivation the fear of coming out second best could ignite. The winning drive was born and baptised in the searing fire of the shame and sheer unacceptability of losing out to others. This was the real spur. Not fame or the ecstasy of victory, but the shuddering possibility of loss. For what I could sense in that tense little body of my daughter, as I held her fast in her elation, was not just gloating, or the ruthless joy she was experiencing in her conquest, but also the utter relief of having finally overcome powerful and tenacious opposition.

Yet, strangely enough, this fierce battle among peers at the top stirred unquiet memories in me. Recollection of a bigger battle waged in the gloom of the bottom far below. A battle fought with abject fear and hopelessness, a strife where the outcome could lead to inconsolable shame and despair, as could wrench the most hardened of hearts. Yes, that is what it was, surely! That was your lot when you came last. There was something so unshakeably mortifying about the bottom place, of how it put you in the eyes of others, one could wish to die rather than writhe in the misery of that ignominious seat. The utter desolation it could bring, I could only imagine. I could not bring myself to think of the possibility of it ever happening to me. But no, that’s not quite true. Perhaps I had known it once, experienced the shame and pathos of it vicariously. I could never forget that. Never forget him who was the cause of it. No, I would never forget Murthy.

It was so long ago that memories had become tenuous with age. But Murthy stood out painfully clear, untouched by recrimination and rationalisation. Defying the self-righteousness with which we bury guilt and remorse. Murthy was the hope of every loser, the balm of all battered egos and the consolation of every failure. A nondescript and forgettable (yet so unforgettable!) boy, who could always be found sitting placidly in the third row in class, never changing his place. No matter what he wore, what modest changes he made to his appearance, Murthy always managed to look the same. He was ever dressed in a limp white shirt that hung listlessly from his bony shoulders. The wide half-sleeves fell ungraciously almost to his elbows. A thin collar showed uncouth creases-the result of a casual hand wielding the iron. His coarse navy blue shorts flared ridiculously below the knees. His thin, angular face had a protruding forehead smeared generously in three strokes of sandalwood paste. Oily hair brushed severely back, rebelled in tufts and spikes. And the bovine eyes below looked shyly at you. His spindly legs sank into knobbly feet and were shod in cracked leather shoes. The off-white socks with ladders and gaping mouths, wilted clear of painfully thin ankles.

Murthy was always there and almost never absent from school. Indeed, the rare occasions when he was absent were sensed by others with unease. As if props had been taken away beneath, with nothing to fall back on. For Murthy had that one universally loved quality which endeared him to all and made him everybody’s friend. Murthy always came last. He came last in every endeavour that classifies people in any formal order of comparison. Whatever the dreaded tests that teachers foisted on the taught, the games we improvised and played in fierce competition, the bottom place was always Murthy’s. The dullards and laggards had their self-esteem intact because no matter how badly they fared, there was always Murthy, who fared worse. The brighter ones had contempt for Murthy, which manifested itself in fond and casual ribbing one reserves for someone beneath notice. Murthy always fumbled the easiest of questions, flunked the simplest of tests. Even the ignorant and foolish could feel knowledgeable and sharp in Murthy’s presence. Yet something was engaging about Murthy, in his shy smile and utter ingenuousness. There was an unsophistication about him which could turn cynicism to wonder. And cleverness lost much of its sheen when confronted with such utter gaucherie!

Sometimes I wondered with listless curiosity what Murthy made of his position. Except for a shy smile and an occasional mild frown, other emotions rarely gained a foothold on his bland, passive face. Saddled with mundane and inconsequential roles, entrusted with lowly chores at which others showed ruffled umbrage, Murthy happily accepted his lot. He ran errands, swept blackboards, carried piles of books and served as ‘twelfth man’ in all competitive events, which served as grist to the mill of school life in the eighth form. Yes, Murthy was everybody’s man. A comfortable, well-worn, homely presence that smoothed out all wrinkles of tension. One who never won, but unknowingly resolved the competitive situations that arose now and then in the ceaseless emergence of events and situations that is life.

Yet there was one to whom Murthy was utterly devoted. Someone, for whom he reserved a special smile. Someone for whom his liking was so nakedly manifest that the recipient himself was reduced to embarrassment. I had often puzzled about this odd streak of attachment and its cause. Yet I knew this attachment had been manipulated relentlessly to bring out the best in Murthy. Conversely, Murthy’s performance always reached a nadir whenever the efforts were directed against the idol. This was often vital whenever a contest hung in the balance, and Murthy’s performance, or non-performance, could tilt the scales towards the favourite. I knew this only too well because the aisle led to none other than me. I was the head of the pack, and the rank and file of the eighth form conformed to my leadership in varying degrees of acceptance. And that was how it should be, I thought. I was the Wolf, wasn’t I? I held the reins, and the drove acknowledged it in a hundred acts of acquiescence.

The masters knew it too, for the sceptre rested naturally in my hand. But there were those who strained at the leash, and the bit often threatened to slip out of the muzzle. There was the Mustang, who was awesome in every game or sport. He always ran me a close race, and his prowess in jumps and throws lent a spring of vanity to his step and weighed in on his abilities. In cricket, his bag of wickets was heavier than the tons he carried on his bat, and woe-betide the goalkeeper who strayed in his charge. The Mustang dodged and veered expertly, unerring in his deadly aim. Then there was the Crab, who was a wizard in math. The most intractable sum would capitulate in the vice of his methodical mind, and in cerebral encounters, his acumen made him a formidable adversary. Finally, there was the Chameleon of many brilliant hues. Always dressed exquisitely and groomed in casual elan, he had a fair androgynous face which stirred longings in budding hearts. Too many of the schoolgirls had swooned below their Plimsoll lines, smitten by his snobbery and practised charm. He was the pied piper I feared most because he drew away so many of my charge with his sinuous appeal.

Yet when things hung in balance, the consensus opinion invariably tipped the scales my way. Perhaps, this too had something to do with Murthy. His unmasked dislike of my rivals and that shy but intense idolatry might have often slanted opinion in my favour. After all, there is nothing that redounds more to the image of a leader than the absolute, almost profane worship of a devotee.

And so my reign progressed, beleaguered but intact. I was vaguely aware that I was enjoined in obligation to a boy, who was always the last and the least by any reckoning. Perhaps it was this half-understood and nagging sense of indebtedness that impelled me to embark on a ‘plot’ to give Murthy his moment of glory. Believing, like many misguided leaders, that power is the signal attribute of leadership and largesse its prerogative, I decided to play God and confer on Murthy the one experience he had never savoured before. I decided to give Murthy a victory. A victory that would stand out in solitary splendour, and shed its luminescence on the giver and receiver alike. It must be a measure of my vanity, indeed vainglory, that I never thought of the impact such an unprecedented triumph might have on Murthy’s subdued and resigned nature. Such considerations never intervened in my righteous, maudlin desire to see my worshipper rewarded. I was imbued with the object of winning my own accolades for a ‘noble generosity’ that would raise me considerably in the eyes of my flock.

In retrospect, I have never been able to force myself to clearly remember every detail and nuance of my unfolding plot on that fateful day. The shame has been too much for me. My plan was simplicity itself. The School’s annual Sports Day was at the threshold. The day was widely regarded as the most important and exciting day of the year in the school calendar. It was of great significance to me, as it served to establish my supremacy in the field. I always emerged as the hero at the end of the day. I was bound to win many of the events, as my all-round prowess in the sporting arena largely prevailed. And it was feared by those who aspired to garner the top honours in different games and sports. My arch-rivals could never shed their foreboding when I was a contender, and envy often caused a frustration to mar their efforts.

Of the many events that studded the crowded hours of ‘Sports Day’, none was so prestigious as the hundred-metre sprint. This headlong, frenzied race, simply known as the ‘dash’, put the winner at the acme of triumphs of the day. Scheduled at what was ‘prime time’ on Sports Day, the winner of the ‘dash’ received the most tumultuous of applause and adulation befitting an emperor. The honours for the cup ceremony of this event were performed by the Guest of Honour, who witnessed the prime events of ‘Sports Day’ that were strung together in the ardent sunshine of the afternoon. This was the race which also pledged my supremacy in the field, and nothing short of a calamitous debacle could clip the wings of my feet and prevent my triumph in this king of all races- the dash.

And I had decided that this year’s ‘dash’ would record its most unlikely winner. I was going to gift the ‘dash’ to Murthy! Pay my debt to this colourless, insignificant boy, whose smooth forehead had never been remotely creased with the mortification of defeat, nor had his heart felt the twinges of pleasure of even a minor victory. I would give him his moment of glory, a gilded memory he could cherish for life. I was sure the flock would somehow know of my generosity and sacrifice and add this exploit to my stature. The difficulties of my scheme, however, became evident as I harnessed the details of my plot. While the majority could possibly be manipulated without unfolding the trappings of my scheme, there were those who would have to be won over, others appeased, and a handful made unwitting tools through discreet and delicate strategies. My arch-rivals would have to be placated separately. The Mustang, in particular, would have to be wooed by concessions as he posed a major threat to my scheme.

I decided to use the Coyote to overcome my hurdles. The Coyote was my staff, my wand of action. He was a shadow who never left my back, the agent who smoothed out the bumps I encountered in the execution of all my plans. It was a question of discouraging some ambitious aspirants and leaning hard on others who ambled through the race as also-rans. But even they could mar the grand design, as they had the potential to deny Murthy his crown. I left all that to the Coyote, who was canny and calculating. I went after the ‘Big Three’ who fell in with my design more easily than I expected. At first, they were sceptical. They were wary of my professed motive and thought of the scheme as a suspicious and even sinister ploy. But once I had inserted the probity of my intentions into their scheming minds, they were persuaded to think of it as a splendid rag. They swore profusely that it would be kept a secret. Of course, the fact that I was forsaking the fruits of a prize event like the ‘dash’, which could dethrone me from my position of pre-eminence, must have weighed with them as they submitted to my ruse.

In the end, with a mixture of cajolery, threats and some sops yielded to the more intractable, the thing was done. The Coyote rigged the event competently, and a field of eight was set up to run the slowest race of their lives. The Coyote had cleverly manoeuvred himself into the role of the Starter. A little confusion artfully created in the take-off could give some extra paces of advantage to our ‘candidate.’ It would also add more credibility to the astonishing conclusion we had planned. And the Coyote was a past master at shrewd ploys. So the plot was sprung, and fruition hung in the balance, as the day of reckoning drew near.

The annual Sports Day finally emerged on a soft and cloudy morning. The rough but pliant stretches of grass enfolding islands of bald earth looked prescient for the day’s events. The maalis had chalked out the lanes with lime and filled sand in the jumping pit. Crepe festoons in bands of riotous colour had been hung in neat scallops along the roofs of the shamianas. The colourful shamianas themselves were held aloft by sturdy bamboo columns. The house teams marked time in a stately array in four clusters, keeping step with a tuneful school band. As captain of the Green House, I stood at the head of my phalanx holding aloft the banner-a shield of worn green silk fringed with yellow tassels and slung on the arms of a freshly painted white upright. The neatly arranged plastic chairs in the shamianas and the stands were already full. Many onlookers stood in clusters, while others straggled along the field’s periphery. The events began as usual in confusion, which sorts out so typically with wayward participants finally being drummed into discipline. The ignorant and indecisive finally merged into order by herd instinct.

Right from the beginning, I knew the field was mine. That day, I could not be denied, and opposition hung its head in shame as I stormed to emphatic victories in a flurry of events. The Mustang mistimed his last jump, and his face tightened in frustration. The Chameleon, who had always dominated the javelin, found his desperate cast well short of mine. The day belonged to me completely. As the crowning event came up for strife, my string of achievements had sated me and sharpened my intent of going through with the plot. Any hesitation or qualms that might have lingered had gone. A fortuitous stroke of luck had been that the Mustang was incapacitated by a twisted ankle, which ruled him out of contention for the ‘dash’. With the tide against him, the Mustang had definitely been thinking of reneging on the deal and getting himself into the ‘dash’ to recover some lost sheen. But that was put paid to now with this setback.

There were seven aspirants on that sunny day who stood up for the ‘dash’ with tingling feet and thudding hearts. And there stood Murthy in the innermost lane, for once in a starched white shirt and stiff creased shorts, unaware as yet of the bounty that was soon to come his way. Did he sense there was something extraordinary about the ‘dash’ today? I flexed my calf muscles idling in the outermost lane and looked at the rest of the contenders. Would they play their part well? It really hung on the Coyote, who stood stiffly at the head, a starter pistol dangling casually from his left hand.

The silence that precedes a climactic event had already spread, smothering inconsequential conversation all around. Now the Coyote moved briskly and arrogantly across the contenders, pushing them back with palms thrust hard against their chests. The Coyote fussed for a long time, making seemingly meticulous adjustments, but actually infusing tension into the competitors like an accomplished showman. When at last the Coyote moved back into position, an irritable restlessness had gripped both spectator and participant alike.

Three times the Coyote fired his pistol in flat bursts and then cried a sharp halt for a false start. Now the participants pawed nervously and stretched leaden legs tentatively to the starting mark. Even my euphoria of a victory-filled day had melted away, leaving me spent and enervated. Then, suddenly, the sharp, flat sound of the starter pistol sounded, and I lurched awkwardly into a clumsy take-off. The others, too, were in hesitant disarray, except for Murthy, who was off in a flash. The Coyote had set the stage expertly, and by the time we gained momentum, Murthy was well ahead. He ran with his head tilted slightly to the right, his face lifted upwards, arms and hands flailing frantically at the side of his straining frame. Murthy always ran that way, pent with heart and soul, and without the least awareness of his competitors in the field. Though he invariably came in at the tail, his panting face reflected that he had put in every ounce of effort in his capacity.

Perhaps it was just as well that he ran true to form, or else his pre-eminent position established so early in the field would have shocked him into some lapse of concentration that could well have cost him his tryst with triumph. Even as I gained on Murthy, I realised with glee that none of the others could close the gap that had yawned between them and Murthy. The field was clear between Murthy and me, and I was closing the gap so rapidly that it threatened to frustrate the intended outcome of Murthy’s glorious run.

Suddenly, it dawned on me that I was not going to concede this run. The mad, delirious chant of the crowd could not be denied. My feet moved of their own volition, and there was no way I could avoid overtaking that dull, unpretentious boy who shuffled, oh so slowly, with a deception of speed! My grand scheme was dying with no hope of resurrection. My plot was coming apart at the seams due to the perfidy of the schemer himself. A classic case of the spider caught in its web. The lust for a win had overtaken me even as I overtook Murthy, and the finishing mark swam closer like a camera close-up in my fevered mind.

And then suddenly the Coyote rose like Inchcape Rock at my side, wheeling along in seeming celebration of a thrilling triumph. I faltered and stumbled, and the complicated mechanics of cross-pulls had me sprawled on terra firma, inches away from the magic line. And my dazed face pressed sideways on the dusty track, saw the amazing spectacle of Murthy’s thin ankles and heaving body flash across the finishing line. It was the Coyote’s master stroke!

In the melee that ensued, only a few had grasped this startling conclusion to the ‘dash’. Then, even as a couple of supervisors crossed to Murthy and clasped him by the arm, isolating him as the winner, incoherent babble broke out among the onlookers. It soon resolved itself into a chant which swelled in volume until the entire field resounded to its echoes. “Murthy! Murthy!”, the refrain heaved in waves, falling and rising like a Mexican wave.

  In that poignant moment, as I shook myself free of nature’s confetti, I clearly remember that there was none of derision or scorn in the crescendo of the chant that crowned Murthy that day. In retrospect, I have always felt that that chant was the paean of exultation and pain. It symbolised the sheer joy in the victory of the common, the ordinary, the unsophisticated and the defenceless. As if all the weariness and pain of mediocrity, and the numberless defeats of the numberless majority on earth, had been erased by this peak of achievement. An unreachable height had been breached that day in glory by one of their kind. That day, Murthy had won something more precious than what was of personal worth to him. Victory had a new visage and put away her aloofness, and came and mingled gladly with those who had never consorted with her.

And Murthy? He stood beyond the tape, transfixed and transported to a world where he was all alone. New and vulnerable, with no clue how to cope. People milled around him, shaking his hand and thumping his back. Now and then, he was swept off his feet by enthusiastic bands who cradled him in their arms, then rocked him violently to the accompaniment of loud chants of Murthy! Murthy! Strangely enough, his numbness and lack of response accentuated the enormity of his achievement. Even the Head came down to shake Murthy’s hand and give him a pat on the back. No one came near me. Those who had rooted for me did not even offer a whisper of commiseration. Only the Coyote stood at hand, his reassuring hand on my shoulder.

The victory stand had been set up, and now a stentorian voice announced the results as clapping broke out in torrents. As Murthy walked dazedly to the podium and ascended awkwardly to the coveted spot, a thunderous ovation broke out with renewed fervour. Murthy’s face, which had that slack and vacant look of not having absorbed his triumph, suddenly focused and broke into a heavenly smile. The ecstasy (so unfamiliar!) that lit up his face, the thanks-giving and the humility that coalesced on that simple face, I will never forget. At that moment, I felt it was worth it. It would have been worth it even if I had lost a hundred ‘dashes.’ The Coyote squeezed my hand in mute acquiescence. Now the tableau froze, and the Guest of Honour made a stately approach to the victory stand. A glittering cup was delivered into the hands of a beaming Murthy to the accompaniment of prolonged applause and clapping.

The moment of glory came and was gone, and Murthy stepped off the stand. The day’s events came to a close, and people who had assembled now broke and faded away like wisps of smoke. The Coyote and I trudged back, kicking random stones in the school’s backyard. I was still wrestling with the opposing emotions of happiness at giving Murthy his slice of heaven and the disappointment of yielding centre-stage to my lacklustre devotee. The Coyote, sensing the struggle, kept a sage silence till I turned around and asked abruptly, “Did you trip me?” “I didn’t, you know,” said the Coyote solemnly, “But I did figure you would lose control right from the beginning, and wouldn’t give the race to Murthy. I had to do something. So I grabbed hold of my bike, which I had parked next to your lane after you all took off. I rode furiously and came hard up to you to be slightly in your way. That’s all.”

I looked at the Coyote and saw no remorse for what he had done. Just a simple conviction that he had done the right thing by putting his straying leader back into line. Suddenly, I heaved, and my rage and frustration came to a boil. All the forbearance, the sanctimonious glow of the sacrifice, melted away inexplicably. The fury and anguish of having been done out of a spectacular win so foolishly took me over so completely that I was overwhelmed by uncontrollable rage. And in that moment, mad and heedless of consequence, I struck fiercely at the architect of my shameful defeat.

The Coyote went down dazedly at this sudden onslaught, as words laced with venom lanced out of my trembling lips. “Take that!” I cried harshly, “How could you dare come in my way? That race was mine for the taking, and you knew that! And if I had decided after all to win it, who were you to cheat me of what was rightfully mine? And all for the purpose of glorifying that silly, clumsy and miserable oaf who couldn’t have overtaken an ant! Do you even realise how foolish and small you made me look in front of everyone out there? They saw me bested by that fool who could never win a game of noughts and crosses! And that ass thought he had run the race of his life, and was preening himself in front of the Head, holding that cup which should rightfully have been mine, but for you. By God, I’ll make you pay…..”

I broke off as a choking sound broke out and halted me abruptly in my rant. At first, I thought it came from the Coyote, who was struggling to get up from the yielding sand. The thought that maybe I had hit him too hard filled me with dismay and foreboding. But no, it was not the Coyote. No, not the Coyote at all. It was Murthy. He had been following us all along, the cup clutched firmly in his hand. And doubtless, he had heard everything. I could not bring myself to look at him, and at that moment would sooner have faced a Gorgon. I, Captain of School, the idol of the entire flock, the Head’s favourite and a hero, could not bring myself to look at that ordinary boy who stood with some awful emotion constricting him to speechlessness.

Then I turned even as Murthy drew back his arm and threw the cup high into the air with all his might. I caught the flash of its steel in the slanted rays of the setting sun and heard the ringing sound as it struck a concrete slab at the far end of the yard and rolled away. It was then that I met Murthy’s eyes and came face to face with something that I had neither the self-righteousness nor the arrogance to confront. In his face, I saw the bleakness of his barren life, which had wandered so sadly and hopelessly everywhere. A face that had not known of any hope or expected the fulfilment of any desire. A face that had never known the glow of encouragement and praise. A face stricken by shame, and the enormity of a betrayal. Defenceless, uncertain, and desolate. And worst of all, a look shattered by the contempt and derision it had seen and heard in one so utterly worshipped and adored.

We looked at each other for a long time, as if this confrontation had set us apart and would be a turning point in our lives. And all our feelings and emotions hereafter would be shaped in the furnace of this terrible encounter. This was also a parting of ways, the end of a relationship from which I would carry away a life-long guilt. And I was leaving behind a hurt, a bewildered pain that could never be explained or atoned for. My eyes dropped, and Murthy turned abruptly and ran. His fading footsteps brought home to me the finality of my offence and the hopelessness of repentance! Then I cried as I had never cried before, and the Coyote wiped the blood from his nose and put his arm around my shoulders.

I never saw Murthy again. During the holidays, I came to know his father had shifted to another town far away to the south. And Murthy never came back to the School. My own days were also numbered at the school, and soon I moved away at the end of the term. In retrospect, I feel it was all for the best. I suppose I could have faced Murthy again after a fashion, for I was still a boy. And youthful resilience would have found the reasons to excuse my actions and their consequences.

But something in me had changed, and I sensed that this experience had been a significant step in the rugged climb of life, which grazes knees and elbows, as boys transform into men. Even as I held my daughter tightly in my arms, I remembered that obscure and pathetic boy and how I had hurt him so cruelly, and how he had looked at me that day. And of the glimpse into his shy and unassuming world, which had helped me to an understanding and compassion, which my daughter would soon have to learn, perhaps on the same road that I had trodden since that day I betrayed Murthy.

Despite a slightly distressed demeanour after the math test, she looked smug enough for the top spot. That evening, when I heard a hail of footsteps in the hallway, and in a swirl of pigtails, she was lodged breathless in my arms, I knew she had beaten her rivals. Probably by the slenderest of margins, which makes triumph all the sweeter.

A buff report card had now been thrust under my nose. Chubby fingers jabbed viciously at the scores as she recounted her conquest. Her gestures were uncomfortably reminiscent of those one sees on television, when frenzied contestants shake fists and glower whenever they score points in the sporting arena. Seeing Tania’s fulsome, almost vicious, delight in vanquishing her rivals, I could dimly comprehend what blazing motivation the fear of coming out second best could ignite. The winning drive was born and baptised in the searing fire of the shame and sheer unacceptability of losing out to others. This was the real spur. Not fame or the ecstasy of victory, but the shuddering possibility of loss. For what I could sense in that tense little body of my daughter, as I held her fast in her elation, was not just gloating, or the ruthless joy she was experiencing in her conquest, but also the utter relief of having finally overcome powerful and tenacious opposition.

Yet, strangely enough, this fierce battle among peers at the top stirred unquiet memories in me. Recollection of a bigger battle waged in the gloom of the bottom far below. A battle fought with abject fear and hopelessness, a strife where the outcome could lead to inconsolable shame and despair, as could wrench the most hardened of hearts. Yes, that is what it was, surely! That was your lot when you came last. There was something so unshakeably mortifying about the bottom place, of how it put you in the eyes of others, one could wish to die rather than writhe in the misery of that ignominious seat. The utter desolation it could bring, I could only imagine. I could not bring myself to think of the possibility of it ever happening to me. But no, that’s not quite true. Perhaps I had known it once, experienced the shame and pathos of it vicariously. I could never forget that. Never forget him who was the cause of it. No, I would never forget Murthy.

It was so long ago that memories had become tenuous with age. But Murthy stood out painfully clear, untouched by recrimination and rationalisation. Defying the self-righteousness with which we bury guilt and remorse. Murthy was the hope of every loser, the balm of all battered egos and the consolation of every failure. A nondescript and forgettable (yet so unforgettable!) boy, who could always be found sitting placidly in the third row in class, never changing his place. No matter what he wore, what modest changes he made to his appearance, Murthy always managed to look the same. He was ever dressed in a limp white shirt that hung listlessly from his bony shoulders. The wide half-sleeves fell ungraciously almost to his elbows. A thin collar showed uncouth creases-the result of a casual hand wielding the iron. His coarse navy blue shorts flared ridiculously below the knees. His thin, angular face had a protruding forehead smeared generously in three strokes of sandalwood paste. Oily hair brushed severely back, rebelled in tufts and spikes. And the bovine eyes below looked shyly at you. His spindly legs sank into knobbly feet and were shod in cracked leather shoes. The off-white socks with ladders and gaping mouths, wilted clear of painfully thin ankles.

Murthy was always there and almost never absent from school. Indeed, the rare occasions when he was absent were sensed by others with unease. As if props had been taken away beneath, with nothing to fall back on. For Murthy had that one universally loved quality which endeared him to all and made him everybody’s friend. Murthy always came last. He came last in every endeavour that classifies people in any formal order of comparison. Whatever the dreaded tests that teachers foisted on the taught, the games we improvised and played in fierce competition, the bottom place was always Murthy’s. The dullards and laggards had their self-esteem intact because no matter how badly they fared, there was always Murthy, who fared worse. The brighter ones had contempt for Murthy, which manifested itself in fond and casual ribbing one reserves for someone beneath notice. Murthy always fumbled the easiest of questions, flunked the simplest of tests. Even the ignorant and foolish could feel knowledgeable and sharp in Murthy’s presence. Yet something was engaging about Murthy, in his shy smile and utter ingenuousness. There was an unsophistication about him which could turn cynicism to wonder. And cleverness lost much of its sheen when confronted with such utter gaucherie!

Sometimes I wondered with listless curiosity what Murthy made of his position. Except for a shy smile and an occasional mild frown, other emotions rarely gained a foothold on his bland, passive face. Saddled with mundane and inconsequential roles, entrusted with lowly chores at which others showed ruffled umbrage, Murthy happily accepted his lot. He ran errands, swept blackboards, carried piles of books and served as ‘twelfth man’ in all competitive events, which served as grist to the mill of school life in the eighth form. Yes, Murthy was everybody’s man. A comfortable, well-worn, homely presence that smoothed out all wrinkles of tension. One who never won, but unknowingly resolved the competitive situations that arose now and then in the ceaseless emergence of events and situations that is life.

Yet there was one to whom Murthy was utterly devoted. Someone, for whom he reserved a special smile. Someone for whom his liking was so nakedly manifest that the recipient himself was reduced to embarrassment. I had often puzzled about this odd streak of attachment and its cause. Yet I knew this attachment had been manipulated relentlessly to bring out the best in Murthy. Conversely, Murthy’s performance always reached a nadir whenever the efforts were directed against the idol. This was often vital whenever a contest hung in the balance, and Murthy’s performance, or non-performance, could tilt the scales towards the favourite. I knew this only too well because the aisle led to none other than me. I was the head of the pack, and the rank and file of the eighth form conformed to my leadership in varying degrees of acceptance. And that was how it should be, I thought. I was the Wolf, wasn’t I? I held the reins, and the drove acknowledged it in a hundred acts of acquiescence.

The masters knew it too, for the sceptre rested naturally in my hand. But there were those who strained at the leash, and the bit often threatened to slip out of the muzzle. There was the Mustang, who was awesome in every game or sport. He always ran me a close race, and his prowess in jumps and throws lent a spring of vanity to his step and weighed in on his abilities. In cricket, his bag of wickets was heavier than the tons he carried on his bat, and woe-betide the goalkeeper who strayed in his charge. The Mustang dodged and veered expertly, unerring in his deadly aim. Then there was the Crab, who was a wizard in math. The most intractable sum would capitulate in the vice of his methodical mind, and in cerebral encounters, his acumen made him a formidable adversary. Finally, there was the Chameleon of many brilliant hues. Always dressed exquisitely and groomed in casual elan, he had a fair androgynous face which stirred longings in budding hearts. Too many of the schoolgirls had swooned below their Plimsoll lines, smitten by his snobbery and practised charm. He was the pied piper I feared most because he drew away so many of my charge with his sinuous appeal.

Yet when things hung in balance, the consensus opinion invariably tipped the scales my way. Perhaps, this too had something to do with Murthy. His unmasked dislike of my rivals and that shy but intense idolatry might have often slanted opinion in my favour. After all, there is nothing that redounds more to the image of a leader than the absolute, almost profane worship of a devotee.

And so my reign progressed, beleaguered but intact. I was vaguely aware that I was enjoined in obligation to a boy, who was always the last and the least by any reckoning. Perhaps it was this half-understood and nagging sense of indebtedness that impelled me to embark on a ‘plot’ to give Murthy his moment of glory. Believing, like many misguided leaders, that power is the signal attribute of leadership and largesse its prerogative, I decided to play God and confer on Murthy the one experience he had never savoured before. I decided to give Murthy a victory. A victory that would stand out in solitary splendour, and shed its luminescence on the giver and receiver alike. It must be a measure of my vanity, indeed vainglory, that I never thought of the impact such an unprecedented triumph might have on Murthy’s subdued and resigned nature. Such considerations never intervened in my righteous, maudlin desire to see my worshipper rewarded. I was imbued with the object of winning my own accolades for a ‘noble generosity’ that would raise me considerably in the eyes of my flock.

In retrospect, I have never been able to force myself to clearly remember every detail and nuance of my unfolding plot on that fateful day. The shame has been too much for me. My plan was simplicity itself. The School’s annual Sports Day was at the threshold. The day was widely regarded as the most important and exciting day of the year in the school calendar. It was of great significance to me, as it served to establish my supremacy in the field. I always emerged as the hero at the end of the day. I was bound to win many of the events, as my all-round prowess in the sporting arena largely prevailed. And it was feared by those who aspired to garner the top honours in different games and sports. My arch-rivals could never shed their foreboding when I was a contender, and envy often caused a frustration to mar their efforts.

Of the many events that studded the crowded hours of ‘Sports Day’, none was so prestigious as the hundred-metre sprint. This headlong, frenzied race, simply known as the ‘dash’, put the winner at the acme of triumphs of the day. Scheduled at what was ‘prime time’ on Sports Day, the winner of the ‘dash’ received the most tumultuous of applause and adulation befitting an emperor. The honours for the cup ceremony of this event were performed by the Guest of Honour, who witnessed the prime events of ‘Sports Day’ that were strung together in the ardent sunshine of the afternoon. This was the race which also pledged my supremacy in the field, and nothing short of a calamitous debacle could clip the wings of my feet and prevent my triumph in this king of all races- the dash.

And I had decided that this year’s ‘dash’ would record its most unlikely winner. I was going to gift the ‘dash’ to Murthy! Pay my debt to this colourless, insignificant boy, whose smooth forehead had never been remotely creased with the mortification of defeat, nor had his heart felt the twinges of pleasure of even a minor victory. I would give him his moment of glory, a gilded memory he could cherish for life. I was sure the flock would somehow know of my generosity and sacrifice and add this exploit to my stature. The difficulties of my scheme, however, became evident as I harnessed the details of my plot. While the majority could possibly be manipulated without unfolding the trappings of my scheme, there were those who would have to be won over, others appeased, and a handful made unwitting tools through discreet and delicate strategies. My arch-rivals would have to be placated separately. The Mustang, in particular, would have to be wooed by concessions as he posed a major threat to my scheme.

I decided to use the Coyote to overcome my hurdles. The Coyote was my staff, my wand of action. He was a shadow who never left my back, the agent who smoothed out the bumps I encountered in the execution of all my plans. It was a question of discouraging some ambitious aspirants and leaning hard on others who ambled through the race as also-rans. But even they could mar the grand design, as they had the potential to deny Murthy his crown. I left all that to the Coyote, who was canny and calculating. I went after the ‘Big Three’ who fell in with my design more easily than I expected. At first, they were sceptical. They were wary of my professed motive and thought of the scheme as a suspicious and even sinister ploy. But once I had inserted the probity of my intentions into their scheming minds, they were persuaded to think of it as a splendid rag. They swore profusely that it would be kept a secret. Of course, the fact that I was forsaking the fruits of a prize event like the ‘dash’, which could dethrone me from my position of pre-eminence, must have weighed with them as they submitted to my ruse.

In the end, with a mixture of cajolery, threats and some sops yielded to the more intractable, the thing was done. The Coyote rigged the event competently, and a field of eight was set up to run the slowest race of their lives. The Coyote had cleverly manoeuvred himself into the role of the Starter. A little confusion artfully created in the take-off could give some extra paces of advantage to our ‘candidate.’ It would also add more credibility to the astonishing conclusion we had planned. And the Coyote was a past master at shrewd ploys. So the plot was sprung, and fruition hung in the balance, as the day of reckoning drew near.

The annual Sports Day finally emerged on a soft and cloudy morning. The rough but pliant stretches of grass enfolding islands of bald earth looked prescient for the day’s events. The maalis had chalked out the lanes with lime and filled sand in the jumping pit. Crepe festoons in bands of riotous colour had been hung in neat scallops along the roofs of the shamianas. The colourful shamianas themselves were held aloft by sturdy bamboo columns. The house teams marked time in a stately array in four clusters, keeping step with a tuneful school band. As captain of the Green House, I stood at the head of my phalanx holding aloft the banner-a shield of worn green silk fringed with yellow tassels and slung on the arms of a freshly painted white upright. The neatly arranged plastic chairs in the shamianas and the stands were already full. Many onlookers stood in clusters, while others straggled along the field’s periphery. The events began as usual in confusion, which sorts out so typically with wayward participants finally being drummed into discipline. The ignorant and indecisive finally merged into order by herd instinct.

Right from the beginning, I knew the field was mine. That day, I could not be denied, and opposition hung its head in shame as I stormed to emphatic victories in a flurry of events. The Mustang mistimed his last jump, and his face tightened in frustration. The Chameleon, who had always dominated the javelin, found his desperate cast well short of mine. The day belonged to me completely. As the crowning event came up for strife, my string of achievements had sated me and sharpened my intent of going through with the plot. Any hesitation or qualms that might have lingered had gone. A fortuitous stroke of luck had been that the Mustang was incapacitated by a twisted ankle, which ruled him out of contention for the ‘dash’. With the tide against him, the Mustang had definitely been thinking of reneging on the deal and getting himself into the ‘dash’ to recover some lost sheen. But that was put paid to now with this setback.

There were seven aspirants on that sunny day who stood up for the ‘dash’ with tingling feet and thudding hearts. And there stood Murthy in the innermost lane, for once in a starched white shirt and stiff creased shorts, unaware as yet of the bounty that was soon to come his way. Did he sense there was something extraordinary about the ‘dash’ today? I flexed my calf muscles idling in the outermost lane and looked at the rest of the contenders. Would they play their part well? It really hung on the Coyote, who stood stiffly at the head, a starter pistol dangling casually from his left hand.

The silence that precedes a climactic event had already spread, smothering inconsequential conversation all around. Now the Coyote moved briskly and arrogantly across the contenders, pushing them back with palms thrust hard against their chests. The Coyote fussed for a long time, making seemingly meticulous adjustments, but actually infusing tension into the competitors like an accomplished showman. When at last the Coyote moved back into position, an irritable restlessness had gripped both spectator and participant alike.

Three times the Coyote fired his pistol in flat bursts and then cried a sharp halt for a false start. Now the participants pawed nervously and stretched leaden legs tentatively to the starting mark. Even my euphoria of a victory-filled day had melted away, leaving me spent and enervated. Then, suddenly, the sharp, flat sound of the starter pistol sounded, and I lurched awkwardly into a clumsy take-off. The others, too, were in hesitant disarray, except for Murthy, who was off in a flash. The Coyote had set the stage expertly, and by the time we gained momentum, Murthy was well ahead. He ran with his head tilted slightly to the right, his face lifted upwards, arms and hands flailing frantically at the side of his straining frame. Murthy always ran that way, pent with heart and soul, and without the least awareness of his competitors in the field. Though he invariably came in at the tail, his panting face reflected that he had put in every ounce of effort in his capacity.

Perhaps it was just as well that he ran true to form, or else his pre-eminent position established so early in the field would have shocked him into some lapse of concentration that could well have cost him his tryst with triumph. Even as I gained on Murthy, I realised with glee that none of the others could close the gap that had yawned between them and Murthy. The field was clear between Murthy and me, and I was closing the gap so rapidly that it threatened to frustrate the intended outcome of Murthy’s glorious run.

Suddenly, it dawned on me that I was not going to concede this run. The mad, delirious chant of the crowd could not be denied. My feet moved of their own volition, and there was no way I could avoid overtaking that dull, unpretentious boy who shuffled, oh so slowly, with a deception of speed! My grand scheme was dying with no hope of resurrection. My plot was coming apart at the seams due to the perfidy of the schemer himself. A classic case of the spider caught in its web. The lust for a win had overtaken me even as I overtook Murthy, and the finishing mark swam closer like a camera close-up in my fevered mind.

And then suddenly the Coyote rose like Inchcape Rock at my side, wheeling along in seeming celebration of a thrilling triumph. I faltered and stumbled, and the complicated mechanics of cross-pulls had me sprawled on terra firma, inches away from the magic line. And my dazed face pressed sideways on the dusty track, saw the amazing spectacle of Murthy’s thin ankles and heaving body flash across the finishing line. It was the Coyote’s master stroke!

In the melee that ensued, only a few had grasped this startling conclusion to the ‘dash’. Then, even as a couple of supervisors crossed to Murthy and clasped him by the arm, isolating him as the winner, incoherent babble broke out among the onlookers. It soon resolved itself into a chant which swelled in volume until the entire field resounded to its echoes. “Murthy! Murthy!”, the refrain heaved in waves, falling and rising like a Mexican wave.

  In that poignant moment, as I shook myself free of nature’s confetti, I clearly remember that there was none of derision or scorn in the crescendo of the chant that crowned Murthy that day. In retrospect, I have always felt that that chant was the paean of exultation and pain. It symbolised the sheer joy in the victory of the common, the ordinary, the unsophisticated and the defenceless. As if all the weariness and pain of mediocrity, and the numberless defeats of the numberless majority on earth, had been erased by this peak of achievement. An unreachable height had been breached that day in glory by one of their kind. That day, Murthy had won something more precious than what was of personal worth to him. Victory had a new visage and put away her aloofness, and came and mingled gladly with those who had never consorted with her.

And Murthy? He stood beyond the tape, transfixed and transported to a world where he was all alone. New and vulnerable, with no clue how to cope. People milled around him, shaking his hand and thumping his back. Now and then, he was swept off his feet by enthusiastic bands who cradled him in their arms, then rocked him violently to the accompaniment of loud chants of Murthy! Murthy! Strangely enough, his numbness and lack of response accentuated the enormity of his achievement. Even the Head came down to shake Murthy’s hand and give him a pat on the back. No one came near me. Those who had rooted for me did not even offer a whisper of commiseration. Only the Coyote stood at hand, his reassuring hand on my shoulder.

The victory stand had been set up, and now a stentorian voice announced the results as clapping broke out in torrents. As Murthy walked dazedly to the podium and ascended awkwardly to the coveted spot, a thunderous ovation broke out with renewed fervour. Murthy’s face, which had that slack and vacant look of not having absorbed his triumph, suddenly focused and broke into a heavenly smile. The ecstasy (so unfamiliar!) that lit up his face, the thanks-giving and the humility that coalesced on that simple face, I will never forget. At that moment, I felt it was worth it. It would have been worth it even if I had lost a hundred ‘dashes.’ The Coyote squeezed my hand in mute acquiescence. Now the tableau froze, and the Guest of Honour made a stately approach to the victory stand. A glittering cup was delivered into the hands of a beaming Murthy to the accompaniment of prolonged applause and clapping.

The moment of glory came and was gone, and Murthy stepped off the stand. The day’s events came to a close, and people who had assembled now broke and faded away like wisps of smoke. The Coyote and I trudged back, kicking random stones in the school’s backyard. I was still wrestling with the opposing emotions of happiness at giving Murthy his slice of heaven and the disappointment of yielding centre-stage to my lacklustre devotee. The Coyote, sensing the struggle, kept a sage silence till I turned around and asked abruptly, “Did you trip me?” “I didn’t, you know,” said the Coyote solemnly, “But I did figure you would lose control right from the beginning, and wouldn’t give the race to Murthy. I had to do something. So I grabbed hold of my bike, which I had parked next to your lane after you all took off. I rode furiously and came hard up to you to be slightly in your way. That’s all.”

I looked at the Coyote and saw no remorse for what he had done. Just a simple conviction that he had done the right thing by putting his straying leader back into line. Suddenly, I heaved, and my rage and frustration came to a boil. All the forbearance, the sanctimonious glow of the sacrifice, melted away inexplicably. The fury and anguish of having been done out of a spectacular win so foolishly took me over so completely that I was overwhelmed by uncontrollable rage. And in that moment, mad and heedless of consequence, I struck fiercely at the architect of my shameful defeat.

The Coyote went down dazedly at this sudden onslaught, as words laced with venom lanced out of my trembling lips. “Take that!” I cried harshly, “How could you dare come in my way? That race was mine for the taking, and you knew that! And if I had decided after all to win it, who were you to cheat me of what was rightfully mine? And all for the purpose of glorifying that silly, clumsy and miserable oaf who couldn’t have overtaken an ant! Do you even realise how foolish and small you made me look in front of everyone out there? They saw me bested by that fool who could never win a game of noughts and crosses! And that ass thought he had run the race of his life, and was preening himself in front of the Head, holding that cup which should rightfully have been mine, but for you. By God, I’ll make you pay…..”

I broke off as a choking sound broke out and halted me abruptly in my rant. At first, I thought it came from the Coyote, who was struggling to get up from the yielding sand. The thought that maybe I had hit him too hard filled me with dismay and foreboding. But no, it was not the Coyote. No, not the Coyote at all. It was Murthy. He had been following us all along, the cup clutched firmly in his hand. And doubtless, he had heard everything. I could not bring myself to look at him, and at that moment would sooner have faced a Gorgon. I, Captain of School, the idol of the entire flock, the Head’s favourite and a hero, could not bring myself to look at that ordinary boy who stood with some awful emotion constricting him to speechlessness.

Then I turned even as Murthy drew back his arm and threw the cup high into the air with all his might. I caught the flash of its steel in the slanted rays of the setting sun and heard the ringing sound as it struck a concrete slab at the far end of the yard and rolled away. It was then that I met Murthy’s eyes and came face to face with something that I had neither the self-righteousness nor the arrogance to confront. In his face, I saw the bleakness of his barren life, which had wandered so sadly and hopelessly everywhere. A face that had not known of any hope or expected the fulfilment of any desire. A face that had never known the glow of encouragement and praise. A face stricken by shame, and the enormity of a betrayal. Defenceless, uncertain, and desolate. And worst of all, a look shattered by the contempt and derision it had seen and heard in one so utterly worshipped and adored.

We looked at each other for a long time, as if this confrontation had set us apart and would be a turning point in our lives. And all our feelings and emotions hereafter would be shaped in the furnace of this terrible encounter. This was also a parting of ways, the end of a relationship from which I would carry away a life-long guilt. And I was leaving behind a hurt, a bewildered pain that could never be explained or atoned for. My eyes dropped, and Murthy turned abruptly and ran. His fading footsteps brought home to me the finality of my offence and the hopelessness of repentance! Then I cried as I had never cried before, and the Coyote wiped the blood from his nose and put his arm around my shoulders.

I never saw Murthy again. During the holidays, I came to know his father had shifted to another town far away to the south. And Murthy never came back to the School. My own days were also numbered at the school, and soon I moved away at the end of the term. In retrospect, I feel it was all for the best. I suppose I could have faced Murthy again after a fashion, for I was still a boy. And youthful resilience would have found the reasons to excuse my actions and their consequences.

But something in me had changed, and I sensed that this experience had been a significant step in the rugged climb of life, which grazes knees and elbows, as boys transform into men. Even as I held my daughter tightly in my arms, I remembered that obscure and pathetic boy and how I had hurt him so cruelly, and how he had looked at me that day. And of the glimpse into his shy and unassuming world, which had helped me to an understanding and compassion, which my daughter would soon have to learn, perhaps on the same road that I had trodden since that day I betrayed Murthy.

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

0 Comments
Oldest
Newest

You Might Like:

Short Stories
Asim Kumar Das

You are on a highway

You are on the highway, crouching over the wheel. And your car is hurtling down the centre of that dotted white line. The miles are racing away, captured by the minutes changing in slow rhythm on your watch. A speeding car a hundred yards ahead looks still, its red lights flicker intermittently.

Minor blemishes on the road are taken in stride by the car, and you sense vibrations occasionally over tiny bumps littering the road. You lean slightly as the highway bends in a gradual curve.

Read More »
Migrant
Asim Kumar Das

Migrant

I am a migrant,

Wife n children

I live in my tent

They in heaven

I drink no water

Eat a little grain

When I’m thirsty

Sip from a drain

Read More »
Short Stories
Asim Kumar Das

The Only Reason

Vantage Rock lived up to its name all right! Gaunt rock, pervasive in panorama.  Stark and sheer rock.  Peaked crags that grabbed the first rays of the sun and wrapped them round their flinty heads. What hard and minatory faces, that plunged to barren earth thousands of feet below!

The sight-seers came in droves, hemming into a promontory that overhung the canyon. A planked platform spaced out over a wide overhang. A railing, high enough to ensure safety, ran along the edge.

Read More »
Poetry
Asim Kumar Das

War ‘Cry’

Why is our earth getting so war-ridden?

Isn’t there any answer out there hidden?

But we keep on asking again and again

Like some parrot that has gone insane,

Yet knows what sought is outside cage.

So do we, if we could but turn the page.

Some think it lies in missiles and drones

In rockets and bombs, exploded phones

Read More »
Poetry
Asim Kumar Das

The Sparrow

One day a sparrow came, alighted on my balcony railing

I, behind stirring curtains, saw her settle down, was glad

That of all the houses standing together, she chose mine.

To rest awhile, and with darting eyes take a second wind.

She saw me, and I knew she would take wing if I blinked

Read More »
Foodless in Gaza
Asim Kumar Das

Food-less in Gaza

There are just twenty of them, would you believe!

The rest are restrained, why not allowed to leave?

Maybe the score bears numberless grains of rice

To fill million stomachs, a little left over for mice.

Divine intervention? So meagre is thy daily bread

Read More »

Let's keep in touch

Be updated on your email for all future posts.

0
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x
()
x